Comprehensive Exercise

Grading Rubric

Grading Rubric

What Team/Individual Points
(1) Software Requirements (Formal Documentation) Team 25.00
(2) Software Design (Formal Documentation) Team 25.00
(3) Implementation (Formal Documentation and Code) Team 25.00
(4) Testing (Formal Documentation and Code) Team 25.00
(5) Presentation Team & Individual 25.00
Journal of thought process Team 40.00
Individual participation and performance based on peer evaluation by teammates and teaching staff observations Individual 10.00
Peer review feedback on other groups’ presentations Individual 5.00
Reflections Individual 20.00
  Total 200.00

NOTE: If you are not present for all four days of the comprehensive exercise, you will not receive full credit for the exercise!

Grading Rubric for Comprehensive Exercise Presentation

    Unacceptable Poor Satisfactory Good Excellent      
    0 1 2 3 4 R (0-4) Wt R x Wt
Presentation Content (Team) Introduction No Introduction.   Introduction was incomplete or missing pieces of title slide.   Introduced group members and topic at start of presentation and had a title slide with project name, group name, and group member names.   1  
Presentation Content (Team) Requirements/Analysis Did not describe the requirements and analysis process.   Partially described the requirements and analysis process.   Fully described the requirements and analysis process.   4  
Presentation Content (Team) Design Did not discuss design options and how decision was made.   Partially discussed design options and how decision was made.   Fully discussed design options and how decision was made.   4  
Presentation Content (Team) Demo of implementation Did not provided a demo of the functionality.   Provided a demo of the functionality, with many errors.   Provided a well-planned demo of the functionality, with few or no errors.   4  
Presentation Content (Team) Testing Did not describe white box and black box tests.   Partially described white box and black box tests.   Fully described white box and black box tests.   4  
Presentation Content (Team) Lessons Learned Did not discuss lessons learned about programming concepts or software process.   Partially discussed lessons learned about programming concepts and/or software process.   Fully discussed lessons learned about programming concepts and/or software process.   4  
Presentation Content (Team) Accuracy Numerous serious errors.   Quite a few minor errors.   Very few or no errors.   2  
Presentation Delivery (Team) Organization Presented information in no logical sequence.   Presented information in somewhat logical sequence.   Presented information in logical, interesting sequence.   2  
Presentation Delivery (Team) Graphics Used superfluous or no graphics.   Used graphics that moderately support presentation and/or are unreadable.   Used attractive graphics that consistently support presentation and are readable.   2  
Presentation Delivery (Team) Content Knowledge Demonstrated no command of knowledge learned in course.   Demonstrated partial command of knowledge learned in course.   Demonstrated full command of knowledge learned in course.   4  
Presentation Delivery (Team) Presentation Length Did not present   Finished the presentation in under 7 minutes or over 10 minutes.   Finished the presentation between 7-10 minutes.   3  
Individual Performance Business Casual Dress Did not dress appropriately in business casual       Dressed appropriately in business casual   1  
Individual Performance Eye Contact Made no eye contact with audience.   Used moderate eye contact with some of audience.   Used good eye contact with entire audience.   1  
Individual Performance Rehearsed Presentation was not rehearsed   Presentation was somewhat rehearsed.   Presentation was well-rehearsed   1  
Individual Performance Delivery Inaudible during presentation   Presented moderately clear, somewhat animated.   Presented very clear, dynamic.   1  
Individual Performance Presentation Length Did not present   Presented for under two minutes   Presented for two minutes or longer.   1  
            Sum (S) X 39  
            Maximum (M) [4 x S(Wt)] X X 156
            Percentage (100 x (S-Deductions)/M) X X